LLC vs S Corps: Choosing the Right Entity for Your Business

LLC vs S Corps: Choosing the Right Entity for Your Business

January 22, 2024
 Min Read

Starting a new business is exciting, but choosing the correct business entity is crucial to success. Limited Liability Companies (LLCs) and S Corporations (S Corps) are two popular business entities for small businesses in the United States.

This article will discuss the differences and benefits of these two business entities and how to choose the right one for your needs.

LLC

An LLC is a type of business entity that combines a corporation's liability protection with a partnership's tax benefits.

In other words, it offers limited liability protection for its owners (called members) while allowing for pass-through taxation, where the profits and losses of the business are reported on the members' tax returns.

Advantages of LLC

  1. Limited liability protection: Members of an LLC are generally not personally liable for the company's debts and obligations.
  2. Pass-through taxation: The LLC does not pay federal income taxes. Instead, the profits and losses are passed through to the member's tax returns, which are taxed at their tax rates.
  3. Flexible management structure: LLCs do not have the formal management requirements of a corporation. Members can choose to manage the business themselves or alternatively, appoint a manager to run the business.

Disadvantages of LLC

  1. Self-employment taxes: Members of an LLC are subject to self-employment taxes on their share of the business's profits.
  2. Limited life span: LLCs have a limited life span, meaning the business may dissolve when a member leaves or dies.
  3. Limited fundraising options: LLCs have limited options for raising capital, as they cannot issue stock.

S Corps

An S corporation provides the same liability protection as a traditional corporation but with pass-through taxation, like an LLC. However, an S Corps has stricter eligibility requirements, and it must meet specific criteria to qualify for S Corps status.

In simple terms, an S Corp is not a separate legal entity you can form; it's a tax treatment or classification granted by the IRS. Any Corporation (C-Corp) or LLC can elect to be taxed as an S Corp, provided they meet specific eligibility requirements.

When you form a business, you create a legal entity like a Corporation (C-Corp) or an LLC. These legal entities have their own set of rules and regulations, and state laws typically govern them. However, once the legal entity is formed, you can choose how you'd like it to be taxed by the federal government. One of these options is to be taxed as an S Corp. An S Corp is a tax classification that allows a Corporation or an LLC to enjoy certain tax benefits.

Primarily, it enables the business to have pass-through taxation, meaning the company's profits and losses are passed directly to the individual shareholders or owners, who then report this information on their personal tax returns. This helps avoid the double taxation that can occur with a traditional C-Corp, where both the corporation and the shareholders are taxed on the company's profits. To elect S Corp status, a Corporation or LLC must meet specific criteria set forth by the IRS, such as having no more than 100 shareholders and only one class of stock. If a business meets these requirements, it can submit IRS Form 2553 to request the S Corp tax classification.

In conclusion, an S Corp is not a distinct legal entity you form but a tax treatment option available to qualifying Corporations (C-Corps) and LLCs. A business can take advantage of pass-through taxation and potentially other tax benefits by electing to be taxed as an S Corp. However, consulting with a tax professional is crucial to ensure that S Corp status is the right choice for your business's specific needs.

Advantages of S Corps

  1. Limited liability protection: Shareholders of an S Corps are generally not personally liable for the company's debts and obligations.
  2. Pass-through taxation: Like an LLC, the S Corps does not pay federal income taxes. Instead, the profits and losses are passed through to the shareholders' tax returns, which are taxed at individual tax rates.
  3. Ability to avoid self-employment taxes: Unlike an LLC, shareholders of an S Corps may avoid self-employment taxes on a portion of their income.
  4. Ability to raise capital through stock sale: S Corps can issue stock to raise money.

Disadvantages of S Corps

  1. Stricter eligibility requirements: An S Corps must meet strict eligibility requirements, including a limit on the number of shareholders, to qualify for S Corps status.
  2. Limited number of shareholders: S Corps are limited to 100 shareholders.
  3. Formal management structure required: An S Corps must have a formal management structure, including a board of directors and regular shareholder meetings.
  4. US Persons only: Foreigners or Foreign Corporations are not allowed to be shareholders of an S-Corp, thus limiting the S-Corp to US residents or citizens only.

LLC vs. S Corps: How to Choose

Choosing the correct business entity can have a significant impact on the success of your business. There are several factors to consider when deciding between an LLC and an S Corps.

Here are some of the critical factors to consider:

  1. Business goals and plans for growth: If you have plans for significant growth, an S Corps may be a better option due to its ability to raise capital through the sale of stock. However, if you are not planning on growing your business significantly or need more flexibility in management structure, an LLC may be a better fit.
  2. Ownership structure and number of shareholders: S Corps are limited to no more than 100 shareholders, whereas LLCs can have unlimited members. An LLC may be a better option if you plan on having many shareholders.
  3. Tax implications and preferences: LLCs and S Corps offer pass-through taxation, but S Corps have the added advantage of avoiding some self-employment taxes. Your tax professional can help determine which entity will provide the best tax benefits for your business.
  4. Management and decision-making structure: S Corps require a more formal management structure and decision-making process, whereas LLCs offer more flexibility. An S Corps may be a better option if you prefer a more formalized management structure.

LLC vs. S Corps: Which one to choose?

Choosing the right legal structure is a critical decision when starting a business. Limited Liability Companies (LLCs) and S Corporations (S-Corps) are two popular options for small businesses.

Both LLCs and S-Corps offer limited liability protection for owners and pass-through taxation. However, some key differences between the two structures could affect your business's tax liabilities, management structure, and more.

Here are some important factors to consider when deciding between an LLC and an S-Corp:

  1. Ownership Restrictions
    LLCs do not have any ownership restrictions, while S-Corps are limited to no more than 100 shareholders. This can be a significant factor if you plan on raising capital through the issuance of stock.
  2. Taxation
    One of the most important differences between LLCs and S-Corps is how they are taxed. LLCs are taxed as pass-through entities, meaning that the profits and losses of the business pass through to the individual owner's personal tax returns. S-Corps are also taxed as pass-through entities, but they must file a corporate tax return and allocate profits and losses to individual shareholders based on their ownership percentage. This can result in more complicated tax filings for S-Corps.
  3. Self-Employment Taxes
    Owners of LLCs are subject to self-employment taxes on all business profits. At the same time, owners of S-Corps who work as employees may avoid some self-employment taxes by taking a reasonable salary.
  4. Employee Benefits
    Owners of LLCs may be able to deduct health insurance premiums on their tax returns. In contrast, owners of S-Corps who work as employees may be eligible for more extensive employee benefits, such as retirement plans.
  5. Management
    LLCs can be managed by the owners or a designated manager, while S-Corps must have a board of directors and officers. This can make S-Corps more complicated to manage, but it also provides a clear hierarchy of decision-making.
  6. Formalities
    LLCs generally require fewer formalities than S-Corps. While LLCs are not required to hold regular meetings or keep minutes, S-Corps must hold regular board and shareholder meetings and keep minutes of those meetings.
  7. Limited Liability
    Both LLCs and S-Corps offer limited liability protection for owners, which means that the owners are not personally liable for the company's debts or legal obligations.
  8. Stock Issuance
    LLCs do not issue stock, while S-Corps can give stock and raise capital from investors. If you plan on raising capital through stock offerings, an S-Corp may be a better choice for your business.
  9. Cost of Formation
    LLCs are generally less expensive to form than S-Corps. However, the cost of formation can vary depending on the state where the business is formed and other factors.

In conclusion, when deciding between an LLC and an S-Corp, it's essential to consider your business's specific needs, including its ownership structure, taxation, management, and funding requirements. It's always a good idea to consult with a qualified tax attorney or accountant before finalizing your business's legal structure.

LLC vs. S Corps:

Feature  LLC   S Corps
Ownership Restrictions  None  1. Restricted to no more than 100 shareholders
2. Not available to Non-Resident Aliens
Taxation  Pass-through taxation on all earnings   Pass-through taxation on earnings allocated to shareholders; must file corporate tax return on remaining earnings
Self-Employment Taxes  Owners must pay self-employment taxes   Owners who also work as employees may avoid some self-employment taxes by taking a reasonable salary
Employee Benefits  Owners may be able to deduct health insurance premiums   Owners who work as employees may be eligible for more extensive employee benefits, such as retirement plans
Management  Can be managed by owners or a designated manager   Must have a board of directors and officers
Formalities  Fewer formalities required   Must hold regular board and shareholder meetings and keep minutes of those meetings
Limited Liablity  Provides limited liability protection  Provides limited liability protection 
Stock Issuance  No stock issuance   Can issue stock and raise capital from investors
Cost of Formation  Generally less expensive to form   May be more expensive to form, due to additional legal and administrative requirements


Conclusion

Choosing the correct business entity is an important decision that can impact the success of your business. While both LLCs and S Corps offer advantages and disadvantages, consulting with a legal and tax professional is essential before deciding. They can help you navigate the complexities of tax law and business formation and ensure you choose the entity that best meets your needs.

Recap of Key Points

  • LLCs and S Corps are popular business entities offering limited liability protection and pass-through taxation.
  • LLCs offer more flexibility in management structure but have limited fundraising options and a limited lifespan.
  • S Corps have stricter eligibility requirements and a formal management structure but offer the ability to avoid some self-employment taxes and raise capital through a stock sale.
  • When choosing between LLC and S Corps, it is essential to consider factors such as business goals and plans for growth, ownership structure and the number of shareholders, tax implications and preferences, and management and decision-making structure.
  • Consulting with a legal and tax professional is crucial in making the right decision for your business.

Importance of Consulting with a Legal and Tax Professional Before Making a Decision

Choosing the correct business entity is a complex decision that can significantly affect your business. While selecting the most advantageous entity may be tempting, it is essential to consult with a legal and tax professional before deciding. They can help you navigate the complexities of tax law and business formation and ensure you choose the entity that best meets your needs.

Final Thoughts on Choosing the Right Business Entity for Your Needs

Choosing the correct business entity is an important decision that can impact the success of your business. LLCs and S Corps offer advantages and disadvantages, and the right choice will depend on your unique business needs and goals. Consult with experienced legal and tax professionals, and carefully weigh your options to determine the most suitable business structure that will contribute to your enterprise's long-term prosperity.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are S-Corps earnings subject to self-employment tax?

S-corps earnings are not subject to self-employment tax. Still, S-corps shareholders working for the company must pay themselves a reasonable salary which is subject to federal payroll tax (FICA).

Can you switch from an LLC to an S-corps?

You can choose to be taxed as an S Corps instead of an LLC by filing Form 2553 with the IRS.

Can a non-resident alien or foreigner own an S Corps?

Non-resident aliens or foreigners cannot own shares in an S Corp, as the IRS has specific rules regarding shareholder eligibility. All shareholders must be U.S. citizens or residents to maintain S Corp tax status.

If a non-resident alien or foreigner were to become a shareholder, the company would lose its S Corp tax treatment.

Do I need an LLC?

Whether or not you need an LLC will depend on your business's specific needs and goals. LLCs offer limited liability protection and pass-through taxation, which can benefit many companies.

How do you form an LLC?

To form an LLC, you must file articles of organization with your state's Secretary of State and pay the necessary fees. It is also essential to obtain business licenses and permits and draft an operating agreement.

How can I be sure my business is eligible for S-corps status?

To be eligible for S-corps status, your business must meet specific eligibility requirements, including being a domestic corporation, having only allowable shareholders, and having no more than 100 shareholders.

How many different kinds of LLCs are there?

There is only one type of LLC, but each state may have its specific laws and regulations regarding the formation and operation of LLCs.

How do I form an S Corps?

To establish an S Corps, start by creating either a Corporation or an LLC, as these legal structures are suitable for S Corps tax status. Once your entity is in place, you can apply for S Corps tax treatment with the IRS by submitting Form 2553 and ensuring you meet the necessary eligibility criteria. Keep in mind that the term "S Corps" refers to a tax classification provided by the IRS, rather than a distinct legal entity. For a smooth process and to ensure compliance with all legal and tax requirements, it's a good idea to consult with professionals in the legal and tax fields.

When should your company become an S Corps?

Becoming an S Corps will depend on your specific business needs and goals. An S Corps may be a good option if you want to raise capital through stock sales and avoid some self-employment taxes. However, consulting with a legal and tax professional before deciding is essential.

Is an S Corps an LLC?

No, an S Corps is not an LLC. While both entities offer limited liability protection and pass-through taxation, they have different eligibility requirements and management structures.

Is it better to be an S-Corp or LLC?

Choosing an S Corps and LLC will depend on your business needs and goals. Both entities offer advantages and disadvantages, and consulting with a legal and tax professional is essential before deciding.

Can you still file an S Corps for me after the business is formed?

Yes, you can file for S-Corps status after your business is formed by filing Form 2553 with the IRS, but there are strict deadlines for filing.

What is pass-through taxation?

Pass-through taxation refers to the taxation of business income at the individual owner's tax rate rather than at the business level. Both LLCs and S Corps offer pass-through taxation, which can provide tax benefits for business owners.

Can a single-member LLC be an S Corps?

No, a single-member LLC cannot be an S Corps. However, filing a Form can tax a single-member LLC as an S Corps.

What are the disadvantages of an S Corps?

Some of the main disadvantages of an S Corps include the stricter eligibility requirements, limited number of shareholders, and formal management structure required. In addition, S Corps are unsuitable for every type of business and may provide a different level of flexibility than other entity types.

What are the benefits of having an LLC?

Some of the main benefits of having an LLC include limited liability protection, pass-through taxation, and a flexible management structure. LLCs also offer greater flexibility regarding ownership structure and the ability to raise capital.

What is the best tax classification for an LLC?

The best tax classification for an LLC depends on the specific needs and goals of the business. Most LLCs choose to be taxed as a pass-through entity, meaning the company's profits and losses pass through to the owners' tax returns. However, some LLCs may benefit from being taxed as a C corporation or S corporation.

Why is S Corps better?

S Corporations are sometimes preferred over other entity types for tax reasons, as they enable owners to avoid self-employment taxes on a portion of their income, similar to LLCs, while also avoiding the double taxation experienced by C Corporation shareholders. In addition, S Corps offers the same limited liability protection as other entity types and provide the ability to raise capital through the sale of stock.

Why is S Corps better than C Corps?

S Corps are often considered better than C Corps for tax purposes because they offer pass-through taxation, which means that the company's profits and losses are passed through to the owners' tax returns. However, C Corps may be more suitable for larger businesses with significant growth potential.

What are the pros and cons of an S corporation?

The main pros of an S Corporation include limited liability protection, pass-through taxation, and the ability to raise capital through a stock sale. The main cons have stricter eligibility requirements, limited number of shareholders, and a formal management structure required. Additionally, S Corps are unsuitable for some types of business and may provide different flexibility than other entity types.

Need Help Setting up your US Company?  

StartFleet helps you with your US Company formation. Apart from helping you to register a US company we offer a lot more:

  • LLC and Corporation formation in Wyoming, Delaware, Florida and all other US States
  • Over $500,000 perks from our partners
  • US Business Bank Accounts Opening
  • Expedited EIN Application
  • Stripe/PayPal application consultation
  • Shopify and Amazon FBA setup consultation
  • Customized Website Policies for your website
table of contents:

Building an online business is a lonely endeavor.
Join our newsletter to get stories of successful global entrepreneurs on how they build their online business.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.